Constructing a Productive Other: Discourse theory and the by Robert F. Barsky

By Robert F. Barsky

This e-book is an outline of the method of creating a productive Other for the aim of being admitted to Canada as a tradition refugee. the full claiming strategy is analyzed with recognize to 2 genuine circumstances, and contextualized through connection with pertinent nationwide and foreign jurisprudence. on the grounds that criminal research is deemed inadequate for a whole knowing of the argumentative and discursive innovations fascinated about the claiming and "authoring" procedures, the writer makes consistent connection with methodologies from the area of literary reviews, discourse research and interplay idea, with exact emphasis upon the works of Marc Angenot, M.M. Bakhtin, Pierre Bourdieu, Erving Goffman, Jürgen Habermas and Teun van Dijk. In so doing, he illustrates a reductive move that unavoidably happens in criminal argumentation which ends up in the displacement the topic from the area of "refugee claimant" to that of claimant as "diminished Other."

Table of Contents

Acknowledgments... nine
advent: the development of the Other... 1
The Chronotope for the conference Refugee Hearing... 17
reading and Transcribing the Other... 37
the hole part: The Discursive Paradigm... sixty five
the center part: The existence Story... 117
The remaining part: The un-Dialogic Other... 167
The Implicit and specific standards for Rendering the choice: the lady as Wtiness and the charm Case... 203
end: The Destruction of the Self... 241
Notes... 247
instances Cited... 253
Bibliography... 257
Index... 271

Show description

Read Online or Download Constructing a Productive Other: Discourse theory and the Convention refugee hearing (Pragmatics & Beyond New Series) PDF

Similar canadian books

To Know Our Many Selves: From the study of Canada to Canadian studies

To understand Our Many Selves profiles the historical past of Canadian reports, which begun as early because the 1840s with the research of Canada. Dirk Hoerder discusses this finished exam of tradition via highlighting its specific interdisciplinary strategy, which incorporated either sociological and political angles. In later years, because the learn of different ethnicities was once further to the cultural tale of Canada, an exceptional foundaton was once shaped for the nation's grasp narrative.

Advances in Artificial Intelligence: 14th Biennial Conference of the Canadian Society for Computational Studies of Intelligence, AI 2001 Ottawa, Canada, June 7–9, 2001 Proceedings

AI 2001 is the 14th within the sequence of Arti cial Intelligence meetings subsidized through the Canadian Society for Computational reviews of Intelligence/Soci et e - nadienne pour l’ etude de l’intelligence par ordinateur. As used to be the case final yr too, the convention is being held together with the once a year meetings of 2 different Canadian societies, pix Interface (GI 2001) and imaginative and prescient Int- face (VI 2001).

Role Quests in the Post-Cold War Era: Foreign Policies in Transition

A state's articulation of its nationwide position betrays its personal tastes and a picture of the realm, triggers expectancies, and impacts the definition of the location and of obtainable strategies. Extending Kal Holsti's early paintings at the usefulness of the concept that of function, position Quests within the Post-Cold warfare period examines the character, evolution, and origins of function conceptions, key facets principally overlooked in a literature captivated with the hunt for fast relevance.

Commissioned Ridings: Designing Canada's Electoral Districts

The place did the assumption for nonpartisan constituency redistributions come from? What have been the significant purposes that Canada grew to become to arm's-length commissions to layout its electoral districts? In Commissioned Ridings John Courtney addresses those questions through interpreting and assessing the readjustment approach in Canada's electoral obstacles.

Extra info for Constructing a Productive Other: Discourse theory and the Convention refugee hearing (Pragmatics & Beyond New Series)

Example text

The Supreme Court ruling which allowed for self-representation beyond the affidavit is based on the Charter of Human Rights and Freedoms, a fact that in some ways limits the powers of the government to make purely administrative decisions as it had done in the past. In effect, Singh overturned the two Federal Appeal Court decisions, Singh v. C. R. and Vincent v. R. (3d), in which refugee status was excluded 34 Constructing a Productive Other under section 7 of the Charter because the threat to life, liberty or security suffered by the claimant did not occur in Canada.

C. R. and Vincent v. R. (3d), in which refugee status was excluded 34 Constructing a Productive Other under section 7 of the Charter because the threat to life, liberty or security suffered by the claimant did not occur in Canada. In short, the Supreme Court ruling on the Singh case in 1985 "reversed and held invalid the power to refuse to entertain an application for redetermination given to the Immigration Appeal Board by the legislation" (Grey "Comment" 499-500). The fun­ damental upshot of the ruling was that although the decision would remain administrative, "every applicant for refugee status was going to get at least one oral hearing, compatible with the importance of the refugee issue" (Grey "Comment" 500).

The United Nations was established for the most part in the interest of protecting the West against itself, an objective that was achieved through the passage of Conventions, Acts and Treaties that serve the interests of its most powerful member countries. S. adhered, in 1968, to the Protocol Relating to the Status of Refugees "and thus became derivatively bound by all the principal provisions of the Convention on the same subject" (Martin 133). N. broaden the definition of "refugee" to include "any person" who suffered persecution in his/her country of origin.

Download PDF sample

Rated 4.90 of 5 – based on 22 votes